LeadershipRuler1

Leadership Evaluation: Four Key Factors to Measure Performance

How should we evaluate a CEO’s performance? Or the performance of any organizational leader? Too often, leadership evaluations — especially CEO evaluations — are based on the previous year’s financial achievements or disappointments. But those can only show us what happened in the past. But what most organizations really want is a tool that can measure past performance and use it to predict a leader’s performance going forward.

A good evaluation should be part of an overall program that clarifies the organization’s direction, provides momentum, and develops future leaders. Having done many kinds of evaluations and leadership assessments over the decades, we’ve found that the most successful CEO evaluations, and leader evaluations in general, share four basic elements.

1. An Effective Leadership Evaluation Structure

To gather a complete picture, this should include pre-planning; feedback surveys; data analysis; a series of interim meetings to clarify and communicate results; and finally, the formal evaluation meeting (with the board, if evaluating a CEO). Before the final meeting, the performance critique has been completed; areas of agreement and disagreement have been identified; and the leader has developed an action plan to address questions regarding both organizational performance and personal development.

2. Objective Information From Multiple Data Sources

Decisions with such sweeping influence on an organization should not be based on information gleaned solely from in-house financial figures, the executive’s self-evaluation, or other internally generated statistics. The lifeblood of a truly effective evaluation process consists of objective and reliable data, best supplied by an outside specialist. This data should come from multiple sources, including 360° degree surveys, background data, and formal assessment.

3. Frank and Open Communication

To be of greatest value to the organization, the evaluation process should be a collaborative, consensus-building experience. So, the goal of the evaluation specialist is to encourage frank and open communication with all participants, creating a positive communication climate.

4. Dialogue About Expectations

This is an all-too-often overlooked aspect of leadership evaluation. But consider: The objective of an evaluation is not merely to measure the leader’s performance, or set target numbers for next year’s performance. An effective evaluation process introduces a dialogue about the organization’s short-term goals and long-term direction, forging a genuine working partnership between the board and the CEO (in the case of CEO evaluation) or between the C-suite and leader (for other positions).

Structuring any sort of leadership evaluation can be difficult; creating one that meets these four criteria requires additional expertise and experience. If you would like a more in-depth look at our own CEO evaluation process, we recommend our article “The CEO Evaluation: Making CEOs the Best They Can Be.”

More blog posts by Dr. Hal Guterman

Related Insights

Privacy Policy of q4solutions.com

Q4solutions.com collects some Personal Data from its Users

 

Facebook Audience Network
Personal Data: Cookies; unique device identifiers for advertising (Google Advertiser ID or IDFA, for example); Usage Data

User ID extension for Google Analytics
Personal Data: Cookies

Google Analytics with anonymized IP, Google Analytics, Google Ads conversion tracking, Display Advertising extension for Google Analytics, Facebook Ads conversion tracking (Facebook pixel), Twitter Ads conversion tracking, LinkedIn conversion tracking and HubSpot Analytics
Personal Data: Cookies; Usage Data

Mailing list or newsletter
Personal Data: address; city; company name; Cookies; country; date of birth; email address; first name; gender; last name; phone number; province; state; website; ZIP/Postal code

Phone contact
Personal Data: phone number

Contact form
Personal Data: address; city; company name; country; date of birth; email address; first name; gender; last name; phone number; profession; province; state; various types of Data; website; ZIP/Postal code

Google Site Search, Google Maps widget, Instagram widget, Vimeo video, Wistia widget and YouTube video widget
Personal Data: Cookies; Usage Data

Google Fonts and Adobe Fonts
Personal Data: Usage Data; various types of Data as specified in the privacy policy of the service

Gravatar
Personal Data: email address; Usage Data

Stripe
Personal Data: various types of Data as specified in the privacy policy of the service

Hotjar Heat Maps & Recordings
Personal Data: Cookies; Usage Data; various types of Data as specified in the privacy policy of the service

Crazy Egg
Personal Data: Cookies; Usage Data

iubenda Consent Solution
Personal Data: Data communicated while using the service

Amazon Web Services (AWS)
Personal Data: various types of Data as specified in the privacy policy of the service

LinkedIn button and social widgets, Facebook Like button and social widgets, Twitter Tweet button and social widgets and ShareThis
Personal Data: Cookies; Usage Data

YouTube button and social widgets
Personal Data: Usage Data

Geolocation
Personal Data: geographic position

HubSpot Email
Personal Data: email address; Usage Data

ZOHO Campaigns
Personal Data: email address

Mailchimp
Personal Data: address; company name; Cookies; country; date of birth; email address; first name; gender; last name; phone number

Instapage
Personal Data: Cookies; email address; Usage Data

ZOHO CRM Email
Personal Data: various types of Data as specified in the privacy policy of the service

AdRoll, Remarketing with Google Analytics, Facebook Remarketing, Twitter Remarketing, LinkedIn Website Retargeting and Google Ads Remarketing
Personal Data: Cookies; Usage Data

Facebook Custom Audience and Twitter Tailored Audiences
Personal Data: Cookies; email address

Akismet
Personal Data: various types of Data as specified in the privacy policy of the service

Google Tag Manager
Personal Data: Usage Data

HubSpot CRM
Personal Data: email address; phone number; various types of Data as specified in the privacy policy of the service

HubSpot Lead Management
Personal Data: various types of Data as specified in the privacy policy of the service

ZOHO CRM
Personal Data: email address; various types of Data as specified in the privacy policy of the service

Contact information

Psychological Associates
8000 Maryland Avenue
Suite 1525
St. Louis, Missouri 63105

Owner contact email: digital@gobrandgo.com